Nov
14
Remember when you used to get the gold stars for doing GOOD things?
Posted by Joshua Hanoud under For Buyers, For Sellers, For Realty Professionals, General Information, Loans
This question was recently posed by the Realtor.com Blogging Team:
The Government and the mortgage industry announced the renegotiation of hundreds of thousands of loans. What do you think the outcome will be?
First and foremost, I’m going to point out that I Think I Should Have Bought a Bigger House. Secondly, I understand and sympathize with the number of people who are in severe financial trouble and at risk of losing their homes…that is an extremely scary place to be and I see it all too often lately.
That being said - from my experience (which I will grant you is extremely limited on a national scale but quite strong on a local level), too many (not “all”) of the folks who are losing their homes are in that position because they ate their equity, not because they were taken advantage of by unscrupulous realtors and/or lenders (keep in mind, I said “many”…not “all”). They took the equity out of their homes and bought new cars, televisions, toys, and generally lived it up for a couple of years in the “ants marching” routine of just going with it and not thinking about the future when the bubble HAD to burst; and lets face it, we all knew it was going to happen…we just didn’t know when.
But that just points out yet again that investing in anything…ANYTHING…even a “sure thing” is a GAMBLE. It’s a really really expensive hand of poker and too many people were playing with imaginary paper money that they didn’t really have to lose.
As far as what the ultimate outcome will be…I’m sad. I’m sad that the money that many people earned and worked hard for that should be going to programs in their community for the overall good of their community is instead going to pay for someone elses mortgage…a mortgage which they used to buy a car. This money didn’t just disappear…THIS MONEY WAS SPENT ON THINGS! This isn’t money that someone stole from all of these people…it’s money that they took out of their homes equity with the understanding (playing the ignorance card doesn’t fly with me when you’re dealing with hundreds of thousands of dollars) that equity changes with the market… and then it was SPENT - and now they’re crying foul because they can’t afford to pay it back.
I’m sorry to say it but there are always consequences to the decisions we make and the actions we take. The people who were responsible with their finances, pay their debts, and don’t get themselves in over their heads (however much they might enjoy the home/boat/cars they can’t afford) deserve to have the opportunity to pick up the foreclosures that are flooding the market- that’s the “gold star” for being a good doobie. This plan to bail everyone out rewards the wrong behavior and penalizes the good.
…and so again I say…I Think I Should Have Bought a Bigger House -gotten in over my head, and used the equity in the “good times” to buy the toys I can’t afford…after all…the government’s paying for it.


Buyer #1 - Buys a big house for $300,000 in 2004 that they can’t afford with 3 year ARM figuring they’ll just refi before it adjusts, then the boom hits harder in ‘05 and early ‘06 and they take the equity out to buy 2 cars and maybe a boat…so now they owe $400,000. Market dropped and now their house is only worth $250,000, they owe $400,000 and their rate is adjusting upwards and they can’t afford it any longer, so McCain wants to buy that loan from their lender, wipe out $150,000 of it, and only have them repay the $250,000 that the home is now worth… To clarify, the government just paid off $50,000 of their house, and paid for their cars and boat in full…with MY tax dollars.
Buyer #2 bought within their means, put a decent amount of money down, and is watching their cash savings get stripped away while they continue to pay the mortgage that they knew they’d be able to afford when they bought the house…and because they’re NOT in pre-foreclosure, they don’t get cars and a boat from the government…
I have to say I’m sad for the American Economy. It’s not going to shrivel up and die, but it is going to hurt (a lot) before it gets better. No matter what happens this is a cycle that we must go through - it is too late to change the circumstances that put us here, and any bailouts are ultimately just bandaids on our broken legs.

Comments (0)